Difference between revisions of "Talk:Switches"

From Hackerspace ACKspace
Jump to: navigation, search
(added netgear gear)
(updated management, QoS list, reference id)
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
= Notes =
 
= Notes =
 +
== [[User:Computer1up|Computer1up]] ==
 
http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/394724/zyxel-gs1900-24e.html
 
http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/394724/zyxel-gs1900-24e.html
  
 
Interessant?
 
Interessant?
 +
== [[User:Xopr|xopr]] ==
 +
added Netgear information
 +
 +
== [[User:Da_Syntax|Da_Syntax]] ==
 +
added D-Link information
  
 
= Candidate long-list =
 
= Candidate long-list =
Line 8: Line 14:
 
Main features:
 
Main features:
 
* Gbit
 
* Gbit
−
* fanless (external power supply, some even have one or two-way PoE
+
* fanless(external power supply, some even have one or two-way PoE)
 
* VLAN support
 
* VLAN support
 
* IGMP snooping support
 
* IGMP snooping support
 
* (semi)managed, some with a webpage, others with a (crappy) adobe air tool ([https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=application&iId=13825 works in wine] and is [http://www.linux-magazin.de/Ausgaben/2012/10/Switch reverse engineered], with a [https://github.com/tabacha/ProSafeLinux linux alternative] made available)
 
* (semi)managed, some with a webpage, others with a (crappy) adobe air tool ([https://appdb.winehq.org/objectManager.php?sClass=application&iId=13825 works in wine] and is [http://www.linux-magazin.de/Ausgaben/2012/10/Switch reverse engineered], with a [https://github.com/tabacha/ProSafeLinux linux alternative] made available)
  
 +
=== Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS116E ===
 +
* comes at around € 105,-
 +
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/132756/netgear-prosafe-gigabit-plus-gs116e.html pricewatch], [http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/unmanaged-plus/gigabit-plus-switch.aspx#tab-features series features] and [http://www.downloads.netgear.com/files/GDC/datasheet/en/ProSAFE_Web_Managed_Switches_DS.pdf datasheet]
 +
 +
=== Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS108Ev3 ===
 +
* comes at around € 45,-
 +
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/424304/netgear-prosafe-gigabit-plus-gs108ev3.html pricewatch], [http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/unmanaged-plus/gigabit-plus-switch.aspx#tab-features series features] and [http://www.downloads.netgear.com/files/GDC/datasheet/en/ProSAFE_Web_Managed_Switches_DS.pdf datasheet]
 +
 +
== D-Link ==
 +
Main features:
 +
* Gbit
 +
* fanless
 +
* VLAN support
 +
* IGMP snooping support
 +
* (semi)managed, web interface or some windows tool
 +
 +
=== D-Link DGS-1100-16 ===
 +
* comes at around € 85,-
 +
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/290114/d-link-dgs-1100-16.html pricewatch], [http://us.dlink.com/products/business-solutions/easysmart-16-port-gigabit-switch/ series features] and [http://content.us.dlink.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/DGS-1100-SERIES_REVAB_DATASHEET_2.01_EN_US.pdf datasheet]
 +
 +
=== D-Link DGS-1100-08 ===
 +
* comes at around € 50,-
 +
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/371040/d-link-dgs-1100-08.html pricewatch], [http://us.dlink.com/products/business-solutions/easysmart-8-port-gigabit-switch/ series features] and [http://content.us.dlink.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/DGS-1100-SERIES_REVAB_DATASHEET_2.01_EN_US.pdf datasheet]
 +
 +
 +
== Comparison table ==
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
!
 
!
−
! GS108E
+
! NG GS108Ev3
−
! GS116Ev2
+
! NG GS116Ev2
 +
! DL DGS-1100-08
 +
! DL DGS-1100-16
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Gbit ports
 
! style="text-align:right" | Gbit ports
 +
| 8
 +
| 16
 
| 8
 
| 8
 
| 16
 
| 16
Line 25: Line 61:
 
| 4k
 
| 4k
 
| 16K
 
| 16K
 +
| 8k
 +
| 8k
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Buffer size
 
! style="text-align:right" | Buffer size
 
| 192kB
 
| 192kB
 
| 6Mb or 768KB
 
| 6Mb or 768KB
 +
| 2Mb
 +
| 192kb
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Max VLANs
 
! style="text-align:right" | Max VLANs
 
| 32
 
| 32
 
| 100
 
| 100
 +
| 32
 +
| 128
 
|-
 
|-
−
! style="text-align:right" | Max LAGs (members)
+
! style="text-align:right" | Max <abbr title="Link aggregation">LAG</abbr>s (members)
 
| n/a
 
| n/a
 
| 8 (2-4)
 
| 8 (2-4)
 +
| n/a
 +
| 8 (8)
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | IGMP snooping
 
! style="text-align:right" | IGMP snooping
 
| v1, v2 & v3
 
| v1, v2 & v3
 +
| v1, v2 & v3
 +
| v1, v2
 
| v1, v2 & v3
 
| v1, v2 & v3
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Supported Multicast groups
 
! style="text-align:right" | Supported Multicast groups
 
| 128
 
| 128
 +
| 64
 +
| 32
 
| 64
 
| 64
 
|-
 
|-
Line 49: Line 97:
 
| no
 
| no
 
| yes
 
| yes
−
|-
 
−
! style="text-align:right" | TOS
 
 
| no
 
| no
 
| yes
 
| yes
 
|-
 
|-
−
! style="text-align:right" | Max source ports (many to 1)
+
! style="text-align:right" | QoS
−
| 7
+
|
−
| 15
+
*rate limiting
 +
*<abbr title="Class of Service">802.1p CoS</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted Round Robin">WRR</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted random early detection/Weighted Deficit Round Robin">WRED</abbr>
 +
|
 +
*rate limiting
 +
*<abbr title="Class of Service">802.1p CoS</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Type of Service: packet priorization">ToS</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted Round Robin">WRR</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted random early detection/Weighted Deficit Round Robin">WRED</abbr>
 +
| 4 queues per port
 +
*<abbr title="Class of Service">802.1p CoS</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted Round Robin">WRR</abbr>
 +
| 4 queues per port
 +
*<abbr title="Class of Service">802.1p CoS</abbr>
 +
*<abbr title="Weighted Round Robin">WRR</abbr>
 +
|-
 +
! style="text-align:right" | <abbr title="Max source ports">Port mirroring (n to 1)</abbr>
 +
| 7 (many)
 +
| 15 (many)
 +
| 1
 +
| 15? (many)
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Power supply
 
! style="text-align:right" | Power supply
 
| 12v/1A ext.
 
| 12v/1A ext.
 
| 12v/1A ext.
 
| 12v/1A ext.
 +
| ext
 +
| int
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Max consumption (W)
 
! style="text-align:right" | Max consumption (W)
 
| 4.5
 
| 4.5
 
| 10
 
| 10
 +
| 4.89
 +
| 9.31
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Fans
 
! style="text-align:right" | Fans
 +
| 0
 +
| 0
 
| 0
 
| 0
 
| 0
 
| 0
Line 73: Line 146:
 
| 5,701,574
 
| 5,701,574
 
| 504,993
 
| 504,993
 +
| 503,585
 +
| 2,827,541
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Weight (kg)
 
! style="text-align:right" | Weight (kg)
 
| 0.55
 
| 0.55
 
| 0.84
 
| 0.84
 +
| 0.42
 +
| 1.53
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Dimensions (WxDxH)mm
 
! style="text-align:right" | Dimensions (WxDxH)mm
 
| 158x105x27
 
| 158x105x27
 
| 286x101x26
 
| 286x101x26
 +
| 171x98x28
 +
| 280x180x44
 
|-
 
|-
 
! style="text-align:right" | Bandwidth
 
! style="text-align:right" | Bandwidth
 
| 16 GBps
 
| 16 GBps
 
| 32 GBps
 
| 32 GBps
 +
| 16 GBps
 +
| 32 GBps
 +
|-
 +
! style="text-align:right" | Form-factor
 +
| desktop
 +
| desktop
 +
| desktop
 +
| desktop/rackmount (11"->19" brackets)
 +
|-
 +
! style="text-align:right" | Management
 +
|
 +
* proprietary tool
 +
* http
 +
|
 +
* proprietary tool
 +
* http(?) [[User:Xopr|xopr]] can check on his model
 +
|
 +
* http (IPv4)
 +
* SmartConsole Utility
 +
|
 +
* http (IPv4/IPv6)
 +
* trap (events over udp)<sup>([[#res1|1]])</sup>
 +
* SNMPv1/v2c
 +
* D-Link Network Assistant Utility
 
|}
 
|}
 +
''Add fields which you might think is valuable''
  
  
−
=== Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS116E ===
+
== Resources ==
−
* comes at around &euro; 105,-
+
# <span id=res1>http://andreas.jakum.net/blog/2012/10/27/new-switch-d-link-dgs-1100-16</span>
−
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/132756/netgear-prosafe-gigabit-plus-gs116e.html pricewatch], [http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/unmanaged-plus/gigabit-plus-switch.aspx#tab-features series features] and [http://www.downloads.netgear.com/files/GDC/datasheet/en/ProSAFE_Web_Managed_Switches_DS.pdf datasheet]
 
−
 
 
−
=== Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS108Ev3 ===
 
−
* comes at around &euro; 45,-
 
−
* see [http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/424304/netgear-prosafe-gigabit-plus-gs108ev3.html pricewatch], [http://www.netgear.com/business/products/switches/unmanaged-plus/gigabit-plus-switch.aspx#tab-features series features] and [http://www.downloads.netgear.com/files/GDC/datasheet/en/ProSAFE_Web_Managed_Switches_DS.pdf datasheet]
 

Latest revision as of 11:58, 5 February 2016

Notes

Computer1up

http://tweakers.net/pricewatch/394724/zyxel-gs1900-24e.html

Interessant?

xopr

added Netgear information

Da_Syntax

added D-Link information

Candidate long-list

Netgear

Main features:

  • Gbit
  • fanless(external power supply, some even have one or two-way PoE)
  • VLAN support
  • IGMP snooping support
  • (semi)managed, some with a webpage, others with a (crappy) adobe air tool (works in wine and is reverse engineered, with a linux alternative made available)

Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS116E

Netgear Prosafe Gigabit Plus GS108Ev3

D-Link

Main features:

  • Gbit
  • fanless
  • VLAN support
  • IGMP snooping support
  • (semi)managed, web interface or some windows tool

D-Link DGS-1100-16

D-Link DGS-1100-08


Comparison table

NG GS108Ev3 NG GS116Ev2 DL DGS-1100-08 DL DGS-1100-16
Gbit ports 8 16 8 16
MAC entries 4k 16K 8k 8k
Buffer size 192kB 6Mb or 768KB 2Mb 192kb
Max VLANs 32 100 32 128
Max LAGs (members) n/a 8 (2-4) n/a 8 (8)
IGMP snooping v1, v2 & v3 v1, v2 & v3 v1, v2 v1, v2 & v3
Supported Multicast groups 128 64 32 64
IGMP snooping queries no yes no yes
QoS
  • rate limiting
  • 802.1p CoS
  • WRR
  • WRED
  • rate limiting
  • 802.1p CoS
  • ToS
  • WRR
  • WRED
 4 queues per port
  • 802.1p CoS
  • WRR
 4 queues per port
  • 802.1p CoS
  • WRR
Port mirroring (n to 1) 7 (many) 15 (many) 1 15? (many)
Power supply 12v/1A ext. 12v/1A ext. ext int
Max consumption (W) 4.5 10 4.89 9.31
Fans 0 0 0 0
MTBF 5,701,574 504,993 503,585 2,827,541
Weight (kg) 0.55 0.84 0.42 1.53
Dimensions (WxDxH)mm 158x105x27 286x101x26 171x98x28 280x180x44
Bandwidth 16 GBps 32 GBps 16 GBps 32 GBps
Form-factor desktop desktop desktop desktop/rackmount (11"->19" brackets)
Management
  • proprietary tool
  • http
  • proprietary tool
  • http(?) xopr can check on his model
  • http (IPv4)
  • SmartConsole Utility
  • http (IPv4/IPv6)
  • trap (events over udp)(1)
  • SNMPv1/v2c
  • D-Link Network Assistant Utility

Add fields which you might think is valuable


Resources

  1. http://andreas.jakum.net/blog/2012/10/27/new-switch-d-link-dgs-1100-16
Retrieved from "https://ackspace.nl/w/index.php?title=Talk:Switches&oldid=5785"